ELAP: Stop Insulting Our Intelligence!

I spent a big part of last week responding to the first draft of the Entry Level Analysis Project (ELAP). I shared it on my social media several times and encouraged everyone in the massage profession to respond. While I do still encourage everyone to respond, I must say that I have some distress at the way this is being presented.

The powers that be seem to be worried that the massage community is lacking enough intelligence and ability to comprehend information. 

The framework being used to disseminate the first draft of the ELAP prevents anyone outside of the closed-door system that launched and produced this document from being able to read, comprehend and comment on it as a whole. Being restricted to viewing one learning objective at a time does not allow the reader to place individual elements in a larger context, which is vital for being able to properly evaluate this kind of work. We are finally being shown the Curriculum Map that the ELAP Workgroup developed, but only in small bits through a keyhole. This strategy is sure to reduce the number of people who would otherwise want to take the time to read and comment on something that is of potential importance to the field.

Over the past three years, people in our field have successfully reviewed and commented on two drafts each of the Massage Therapy Body of Knowledge and the Alliance’s Core Competencies for Massage Therapy Teachers — both lengthy and complex standards documents.

In addition, there are some other flaws in the document and the entire process. Instead of my repeating every word Sandy Fritz has said, I suggest you click on this link and read her blog. Fritz makes it very clear she wants this project to succeed, but brings to light a lot of issues that need to be corrected.

If you’re a regular reader, you know I haven’t been thrilled about this from the beginning–and I do mean the very beginning — starting with the way it was initially presented at a Leadership Summit when it was not on the approved agenda for discussion. If anyone other than Bob Benson, Chairman of ABMP, had done that, they would probably have been told to sit down and request that it be a possible agenda item for the next meeting.

In the meantime, I have warmed up to the idea — in theory — but I have some issues with the way it is presented. Like Sandy, I object to the document telling us how to teach. This is supposed to be about entry-level information and what that is–not how to get it across. There are also some faulty assumptions–like the one that all massage teachers are familiar with Bloom’s Taxonomy. Sorry to disappoint you, but some teachers couldn’t tell you what a taxonomy is if their life depended on it — particularly at those schools where last year’s students are this year’s teachers.

This is a research project. It’s not going to be the law — at least not in my lifetime. It’s intended to be the road map for what should be presented in entry-level massage programs. A lot of work has gone into it, and I do have appreciation that it has been a collaboration among our professional organizations. However, these organizations need to realize that there are intelligent people out here who want to look at the big picture instead of having it spoon-fed to us in kibbles and bits. I believe the Workgroup will get more and better feedback if the Curriculum Map as a whole was available for comment.

If you think this is a good idea, then contact the leaders of ABMP and AMTA. In the meantime, this is what we have, and I urge you to take the time to read it, take the surveys, and comment.

11 thoughts on “ELAP: Stop Insulting Our Intelligence!

  1. Pingback: ELAP: Stop Insulting Our Intelligence! | WIBB

  2. Pingback: The Massage Pundit | Massage Magazine | Massage Blog

  3. Sandy Fritz

    – begged for this project to turned over to independent educational experts and it didn’t happen so now this is the result. An independent edcation cosulting firm with a trained project manager would have been able deliver a more usable document. So now what?

  4. Tara

    Thank you so much for this! This is how I felt in school the whole time – college/secondary education was supposed to be hard but it was a piece of cake because really the college is more concerned with having a high rate of graduating students than making their courses hard enough!

  5. Sally G.

    I have tried to “get into” reviewing this project two times in the past couple of weeks. I feel like Sweet Georgia Brown and slightly unprofessional but I just have to say I don’t have time for this. I think the method of delivery is so annoying that I doubt if I will make a third attempt. Each section of the video just slowly goes on and on and in the first 5 minutes I click out of it. I am in private practice, it’s midnight and I have more important things to do for my business and the industry than review this information the way it is being delivered. If this had been delivered in a more concise method that I could just read and click I probably would have participated. At best, I tried but I will probably not participate. Which is a shame because I can tell you I normally have a very participating personality.

  6. Diane

    It is a shame that the powers that be have chosen to make it difficult for us to evaluate the entire document so we can have a true discussion based on the facts.
    It appears to be the way the organizations believe they are protecting us from ourselves. Unfortunately they do not give us credit for being intelligent thinking people, or they are afraid to have true discussions with intelligent people?
    If only they understood that amazing things can occur when you have true conversations based on facts and not just opinions.

  7. Galano@bing.com

    I’m still learning from you, but I’m making my way to the top as well. I certainly liked reading everything that is written on your site.Keep the information coming. I loved it!

  8. fast credit

    I’ve been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or blog posts on this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. Reading this information So i’m happy to convey that I’ve a very good uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to don’t forget this site and give it a look regularly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *